探花视频

I grieve as I watch Ukraine鈥檚 student generation forced to take up arms

As war descends on Europe again, how many of the idealistic young scholars defending their country against invasion will live full lives, muses Keith Burnett

Published on
March 20, 2022
Last updated
March 20, 2022
A Ukrainian soldier
Source: iStock

Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori. It is sweet and fitting to聽die for聽one鈥檚 country.

Did you hear on the news last week a聽version of聽Horace鈥檚 words, incorporated into one of Wilfred Owen鈥檚 most famous war poems, spoken by a聽young student soldier guarding a聽Ukrainian checkpoint on聽the outskirts of聽Kyiv?

As an old teacher, I聽could not but cry for those young men, caught up in Vladimir Putin鈥檚 brutal invasion of their country. They made me think of all the scholars I聽have taught over the years, and of the lives they went on to live 鈥 lives that may well be denied to many of Ukraine鈥檚 current generation of聽students.

I grieve for all those already lost to this awful conflict, and those who suffer because of聽it. But the sight of those young men has hit me hardest. It聽made me think, too, of the many times I聽have read down lists of names during annual acts of remembrance. It聽reminded me of the countless times I聽passed the monument to the scholarly fallen in the quadrangle of my Oxford college while walking back to the physics department after decades of聽lunches.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

I have often mused on those symbols of loss, wondering about all the lives cut short. But I聽never thought I聽would again see teenage students facing death. I聽never thought, 101聽years after the publication of Owen鈥檚 shocking depiction of the First World War鈥檚 reality, to hear them explain their decision to bear arms with all the vigour, courage and, yes, naivety of聽youth.

How can the world deny these young so much? How can their joy be snuffed out so early? It聽is hard to聽comprehend.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

It does not need a war, of course, to end lives prematurely. I聽remember, in the chapel of another Oxford college, hearing the heart-rending words of a Russian father at the funeral of his brilliant physicist son, , who had died at just聽44. The unspeakable loss of a child knows no聽geographical boundaries.

I don鈥檛 suppose many readers will have read Mr.聽Britling Sees聽It Through, but H.鈥塆. Wells鈥 novel about the experience of a British writer in the First World War comes to me again now. The protagonist hires a young German student to tutor his even younger son. Both die in the war, and the book ends as the two fathers meet after the armistice and unite in grief and hope for a world where no聽one has to bear such pain.

I have at times been rather sharp with those who are quick to criticise our students for their idealism or their politics 鈥 or, latterly, for their 鈥渨okeness鈥. I聽have reminded them of the droves of students, apprentices and other youngsters who were the first to volunteer in what my grandparents called the Great War. They were indeed to melt like snowflakes 鈥 but only because of the furnace of violence they marched聽into.

So what is our duty at this time?

First, it is to use our freedom and peace to offer safe refuge, to look after as many as we can of those who escape from this grievous conflict. After all, we owe so much to the precious generation of scholar refugees from Nazi Germany, who so did much to build our present-day universities and to聽whom we owe so聽much.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

The placing of those scholars into UK universities was greatly aided by the formation of the Council for At-Risk Academics (Cara). We should continue to support wholeheartedly the work of such organisations. From its founding in聽1933 to its work with the persecuted of Syria and Afghanistan, Cara has taught us what hospitality and solidarity really mean.

And we must find ways to live together in our privileged communities, seeking understanding rather than dominance. We must rededicate ourselves to researching and heading off the causes of conflict, from food production to energy security. And we must preserve the freedom to聽seek truth and to聽question what Wilfred Owen called 鈥渢he old聽lie鈥: dulce et decorum聽est.

We should do this for our students, for our children and for theirs. For what world will be theirs if we ever stop striving for these ideals?

Sir Keith Burnett is chair-elect of the Institute of Physics and chair of the Nuffield Foundation.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT