探花视频

Research Excellence Summit: You can鈥檛 escape Brexit

Wherever you are, populism and its effect on universities is never far from conversation, finds Chris Parr

Published on
July 4, 2017
Last updated
June 22, 2023
Brexit negotiations sign

You can't get away from Brexit. Even at a research excellence summit in Taiwan,聽it keeps rearing its head. As does Donald Trump.

It might be because I'm English 鈥 or maybe the whole world is obsessed 鈥 but populism seems to be at the front of the queue when it comes to topics people want to discuss. In the lift: what does Brexit mean for UK research funding?聽At dinner: what does Brexit mean for tuition fees?聽At the bar:聽what does Brexit mean for international recruitment?

I鈥檓 at the聽THE Research Excellence Summit,聽hosted in partnership with China Medical聽University in Taichung, and聽the surge of populism has also made聽its way from聽informal chats聽into the presentations.

鈥淎ustralia basked in the post-Brexit and post-Trump moments,鈥 University of Sydney deputy vice-chancellor (research), Duncan Ivison,聽told delegates 鈥 describing them as 鈥渕oments when people looked for alternatives鈥,聽with students and staff looking for English-speaking universities suddenly less enamoured by the UK and US.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

There was聽laughter from the audience when it was pointed out that聽on the day the聽US聽election result was announced, there was a 17-fold increase in the number of people looking for jobs in Canada 鈥 an alternative聽destination.

That basking, though, was short-lived, Professor Ivison explained. In April, the Australian government 鈥 in a populist move of its own 鈥 announced a crackdown that would see some academic jobs become ineligible for visas. The logic? According to prime minister Malcolm Turnbull (sounding suspiciously like Trump), it was 鈥渢o put Australians and Australian jobs first鈥.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

鈥淛ust at the moment when we should have been capitalising,鈥 Professor Ivison told the summit, the government had opted to send out a negative, unwelcoming message.

The story in Australia, however, has a happier ending (if you're a university leader, at least). Universities 鈥渉ad to work ferociously鈥 in an attempt to overturn the changes, Professor Ivison explained. But they 鈥 along with other protestors 鈥 were successful. Last week, ministers announced that lecturers and other university staff would now be聽eligible for four-year visas, with a pathway to permanent residency.聽

"Universities are not immune to the global rise of populism," Professor Ivison said. 鈥淲e cannot be complacent.鈥

Later in the day, another speaker, Shin Sung-chul聽鈥 president of the Korea Institute of Advanced Technology 鈥 told delegates: 鈥淚f you are not happy with the [research] funding situation in your country, come to Korea.鈥

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

He was reacting to a discussion about the challenges of running a university in Taiwan 鈥 where government funding has not increased sufficiently in recent years, and where a strong belief that university attendance should be affordable has led to government restrictions on how much universities can charge for tuition.

However, while his remarks addressed Taiwan, they were felt acutely by attendees with US and UK connections. They have much in common, after all, with the聽words of聽both French president Emmanuel Macron and Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau, both of whom聽are keen聽to聽attract top university staff.

Macron has spoken openly 鈥 and often 鈥 about聽his interest in attracting聽researchers and scientists to France. He senses an opportunity, post-Brexit and Trump, to聽establish France as an international research hub.聽He聽even set up a website to lure US researchers disaffected by the country鈥檚 withdrawal from the Paris Climate聽agreement to France, and unhappy post-Brexit British scholars should cross the Channel too.

Canada, meanwhile, has reiterated its commitment to climate change research, relaxed immigration processes for visiting academics, and made it easier for international students to become citizens.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

We all know that higher education is an international business. But listening to speakers from across the world at a conference attended by delegates from universities in Europe, North America, and across the Asia-Pacific region, the challenge of recruiting the 鈥渂est鈥 scholars is crystal clear.

What is also clear is that when some countries send out the kinds of messages that don鈥檛 appeal to academics, there will always be another country waiting to try to poach them.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

聽Chris Parr is digital and communities editor of 探花视频.

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT