探花视频

Universities offer bastions of hope

After a year where universities were buffeted by forces beyond their control, the winter brings time for reflection and appreciation of their vital role

Published on
December 20, 2018
Last updated
December 20, 2018
Anti-Brexit Santa
Source: Reuters

A lot has been thrown at聽higher education over the past 12 months. In fact, it聽has felt at times as though universities have been up in stocks with a聽baying mob launching mouldering tomatoes at them 鈥 although for what crimes it has not always been easy to say.

In the UK, 2018 began with strikes reflecting deep divisions over the future of the Universities Superannuation Scheme. The action forced a retreat on plans that could have slashed retirement incomes, and to a review that seems to have found a way to largely preserve current arrangements.

It was a year in which higher education lost not one but two ministers: first in a reshuffle, and then with a resignation. Both ultimately swapped ministerial posts for the back benches to speak out on the dangers of Brexit 鈥 and, in Jo聽Johnson鈥檚 case at least, to campaign for a聽second referendum.

As for the UK鈥檚 third universities minister of聽2018, Chris Skidmore awaits the recommendations of the Augar review into university funding, which many fear will pave the way for a cut in the tuition fee cap that could also spell a reduction in the unit of resource.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

This was not the UK鈥檚 only major review of聽the year. Others with particular significance for higher education included this week鈥檚 decision by the Office for National Statistics on how to account for tuition fee debt in the national accounts, and this summer鈥檚 Migration Advisory Committee report, which failed to deliver the hoped-for softening on students鈥 place in net migration statistics.

Brexit, of course, was the defining story for the country once again, with an alarming lack of clarity continuing to cloud everything from the future of research funding to student and academic flows.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

What else has made headlines?

In Australia, there has been growing disquiet about the saturation of international students and about the standards that are being applied by institutions keen to pile them聽in.

There was also a shock wave that reverberated around the world when it emerged that research grants approved by funding agencies had been vetoed by a minister in a clear breach of academic freedom and autonomy, followed by the introduction of a 鈥渘ational interest鈥 test on research funding decisions.

In the rankings, China continued its march up the tables, with astonishing levels of funding producing steady improvement at all levels, and helping Tsinghua University to leapfrog the National University of Singapore as Asia鈥檚 top-ranked institution.

It was also the year when it emerged that China鈥檚 scholarly output 鈥 as measured by the proportion of authors on published research papers 鈥 had overtaken that of the US, and of聽continued concerns about international students taking research 鈥渟ecrets鈥 back to China from the West.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

In the US, Donald Trump dominated proceedings for a second year, with campus themes including freedom of speech and affordability, while in Europe the crisis for scholarship in Turkey continued and the travails of the Central European University came to a head when it was forced out of Hungary.

Many of the big issues outside higher education touched universities, too.

The #MeToo movement led to numerous tales of harassment, sexism and abuse, many of which were told in the pages of 探花视频, while concern about the role of universities in the development of artificial intelligence and data ethics also rumbled on 鈥 the Cambridge Analytica scandal providing a particular flashpoint.

So there has been plenty to write about.

This week, in a double bill of features, we take the foot off the gas and make space for some end-of-year reflections.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Among them is a winter story from John Gilbey that imagines a post-apocalyptic frozen wasteland. What, he asks, would you need if you had to rebuild society from scratch? The answer, of course, is a university. Let鈥檚 hope 2019 doesn鈥檛 get as bad as that. But it鈥檚 nice to know you鈥檙e there if it does!

john.gill@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT